Schoharie County NYGenWeb Site

Pine Grove Cemetery
Town of Broome, New York

latitude 42 31' 52" N; longitude 74 15' 35" W
view Google location map

Listings on this page are not necessarily complete and may not represent all of the stones in this cemetery. Please send additional submissions and corrections to Doug Boyer

Directions: State Rt 145 approximately 2 miles south of Middleburgh village. Left on East Hill/Gridley Rd. Right on East Hill Rd. Right on Anderson Rd. left on Kelsey Hill Rd. Left on Pine Bush Rd. Cemetery on the right.

Submitted by Steve & Anne LaMont
Additional contributions by Walt Mehrer

If anyone would like more information on these people, we may have it. I read the old Middleburgh News and copy any information about the people of Huntersland and have it in notebooks by family. Steve and I would be happy to help anyone out. Anne

Name Birth Death Age Spouse Child 1 Child 2 Child 3 Father Mother Notes
Armlin, Lodema 1860 1823   Chichester, Wesley            
Babcock, John H   4-12-1907 76y             Co. D 134 NY Vol
Babcock, Phylena 5-10-1825 7-3-1891   Canady, Paul            
Barkman, Celestia 1861 1918   Hoose, Abram M            
Barlow, Helen 7-27-1829 11-9-1905   Hallenbeck, John            
Becker, Carrie 1-12-1874 9-29-1913   Becker, Orlin G       Borthwick, Arthur G Hummel, Libbie  
Becker, Orlin G 1870 1919   Borthwick, Carrie D            
Bell, Cornelia   6-5-1881 72y2m14d Bell, Henry William          
Bell, Henry   4-22-1881 74y8d Bell, Cornelia William          
Bell, William H   3-15-1861 22y11m23d         Bell, Henry Bell, Cornelia  
Benjamin, Edwin 1822 1907   Turner, Bertha            
Benjamin, Jacob L. 1823 1898   Church, Maryett John L          
Benjamin, John L 1862 1867           Benjamin, Jacob L Church, Maryett  
Benjamin, McKendre   1888 30y4m              
Benjamin, Theodore C 1850 1919   Chapman, Ellen M            
Berkner, Elise M 1898     Berkner, Paul K            
Berkner, Heinz 1-13-1920 12-21-1993   Winans, Norma            
Berkner, Paul K 1894 1963   Berkner, Elise M            
Billings, Burton L   6-28-1891 24y7m10d              
Billings, Peter L 1834 1913   Brayman, Amilia A            
Borthwick, Arthur G 1-7-1846 6-27-1888   Hummel, Libbie Carrie D          
Borthwick, Cornelia L 1848 1924   Day, Daniel Ezero Ralph B          
Borthwick, Dalinda   2-6-1930               see note 1
Borthwick, George J   6-22-1902 67y1m Hagadorn, Polly           see note 1
Borthwick, Margaret M   2-18-1868                
Borthwick, Nancy Jane 6-27-1840     Scutt, Richard R           see note 1
Borthwick, Robert   6-5-1884 85y1m3d Bushnell, Anna S            
Brand, Eva 1856 1925                
Brayman MD, Edgar E 1856 1909                
Brayman, Amelia A 1835 1921   Billings, Peter L            
Brayman, Ernestine 1881 1964   Brayman, Fred Esther A          
Brayman, Esther A 1911 1938           Brayman, Fred Brayman, Ernestine  
Brayman, Fred 1880 1965   Brayman, Ernestine Esther A          
Brayman, William Henry 1841 1893   Cole, Alzinia            
Bushnell, Anna S   1880 77y6m Borthwick, Robert            
Chapman, Ellen M 1855 1934   Benjamin, Theodore C            
Chapman, Harry 1819 1899   Williams, Nancy            
Chichester, Nellie 1885 1960   Wilber, Hobert J            
Chichester, Sophronah 1832 1902   Taylor, John            
Chichester, Wesley 1849 1919   Armlin, Lodema            
Church, Maryett 1826 1906   Benjamin, Jacob L John L          
Cole, Alzinia 1839 1913   Brayman, William Henry          
Couchman, Eliza Ann 2-5-1828 5-12-1918   Rivenburgh, Norman Ervin baby        
Couchman, Hobert 1873             Couchman, Phillip Ellis, Clarisa  
Couchman, Ida A 1858 1916   Dutton, Robert J            
Couchman, Phillip 1830 1900   Ellis, Clarisa Hobert          
Coventry, Emma 1863 1927   Hollenbeck, Menzo L            
Day, Daniel Ezera 1845 1918   Borthwick, Cornelia L Ralph B          
Day, Ralph B 1876 1937           Day, Daniel Ezera Borthwick, Cornelia L  
Dutton, Robert S 1858 1925   Couchman, Ida A            
Ellis, Clarisa 1835 1814   Couchman, Phillip Hobert          
Estes, Charles 1852 1912   Estes, Nellie S LeRoy R         see note 1
Estes, LeRoy R 1903 1966           Estes, Charles Estes, Nellie S see note 1
Estes, Nellie S 1876 1953   Estes, Charles LeRoy R         see note 1
Farquher, Mary M 1850 1914   Taylor, Renselaer            
Frankel, Eva 1885 1972                
Frankel, Hans 1912 1991                
Frankel, John 1880 1971                
Frankel, Lillie 1885 1972                
Frankel, Phillip 1895 1970                
Goodrich, Agnes B 1869 1961   Goodrich, William Clifford          
Goodrich, Clifford 1899 1900           Goodrich, William Goodrich, Agnes B.  
Goodrich, William 1865 1950   Goodrich, Agnes B Clifford          
Hagadorn, Polly   12-21-1873 58y6m22d Borthwick, George J.           see note 1
Hollenbeck, Menzo L 1859 1945   Coventry, Emma            
Hummel, Libbie 10-29-1842     Borthwick, Arthur G. Carrie D.          
Kelsey, Ansel W 10-27-1810 11-22-1893   Post, Rebecca S.            
Kelsey, infant 8-21-1879 8-21-1879           Kelsey, Elmer Kelsey, Luch  
Leonard, Cornelia J. 1838 1903   Taylor, Harry O            
Lloyd, Randolph K 1942 1942 5w         Lloyd, M. Lloyd, V.  
Lord, Ann 7-20-1817 12-1-1897   Palmer, David William James George      
Lorenzo, Bernice Kay 1937 1937 9w         Lorenzo, Bernard Lorenzo, Belle  
Palmer, David 2-17-1814 5-31-1890   Lord, Ann William James George      
Palmer, George 3-31-1850 5-11-1874           Palmer, David Lord, Ann  
Palmer, James 9-28-1847 12-28-1881           Palmer, David Lord, Ann  
Palmer, William 6-10-1843 12-5-1869           Palmer, David Lord, Ann  
Parslow, Almira 1835 1909   Rivenburgh, Peter            
Porter, James M 1840 1917   Wainwright, Matilda           NY Hvy Art., Pvt. F&D 7th Reg
Posson, Ida 1863 1904   Turner, Augustus Victor Guy Maud May        
Post, Rebecca S 10-16-1817 1-30-1896   Kensey, Ansel            
Rivenburgh, Edwin B 4-23-1879 5-4-1884           Rivenburg, Orsen Sitzer, Libbie  
Rivenburg, infant 5-7-1881 5-12-1881 5d         Rivenburg, Orsen Sitzer, Libbie  
Rivenburg, Orsen 4-18-1850 11-4-1924   Sitzer, Libbie Erwin B. Gerda May infant      
Rivenburgh, baby 3-2-1858 3-30-1858           Rivenburgh, Norman Couchman, Eliza Ann  
Rivenburgh, Elva 1866 1944                
Rivenburgh, Elva   12-5-1866                
Rivenburgh, Ervin B 7-23-1859 12-25-1864 5y5m2d         Rivenburgh, Norman Couchman, Eliza Ann  
Rivenburgh, Gerda May 8-25-1877 9-4-1880           Rivenburg, Orsen Sitzer, Libbie  
Rivenburgh, Norman 3-18-1824 5-13-1919   Couchman, Eliza Ann Ervin baby        
Rivenburgh, Peter 1835 1916   Parslow, Almira            
Roe, Wetsel 1835 1917   Turner, Almira            
Sadlow, Elsa I 1904 1951                
Sanford, Adaline L 1852     Snyder, Abram H            
Scutt, Mary 1878     Cain, Charles            
Scutt, Richard R 5-26-1836 12-8-1910   Borthwick, Nancy Jane           see note 1
Sitzer, Libbie 5-2-1854 12-23-1903 (obituary) Rivenburg, Orsen Erwin B. Gerda May infant      
Snyder, Abram H 1832 1912   Sanford, Adaline L            
Tayler, Chauncy 12-13-1856 7-22-1892                
Taylor, Harry O 1817 1858   Leonard, Cornelia J            
Taylor, Henry O   4-30-1858 41y2m16d              
Taylor, John 1829 1909   Chichester, Sophronah            
Taylor, Renselaer 1851 1937   Farquher, Mary M            
Taylor, Robert E 1857 1931   Wood, Celestine            
Thorington, Frances 1851 1936   Wilber, Abram            
Turner, Agnes   12-10-18??           Turner, Austin Turner, Evelyn  
Turner, Agustus 1848 1933   Posson, Ida Victor Guy Maud May        
Turner, Almira 1838 1915   Roe, Wetsel            
Turner, Bertha 1826 1904   Benjamin, Edwin            
Turner, Calenda   1-7-1879 75y Turner, James            
Turner, George   5-1887 27y28d              
Turner, James 10-17-1795 1-7-1863   Turner, Calenda            
Turner, Maud May 1903 1916           Turner, Agustus Posson, Ida  
Turner, Victor Guy 1899 1912           Turner, Agustus Posson, Ida  
Turner, Youngs   4-27-1866 36y4m2d              
Van Tassel, Flora   9-22-1891 30y Van Tassel, Lorenzo            
Van Tassel, Frank 1901 1905           Van Tassel, Lorenzo Wolford, Hattie  
Van Tassel, Lorenzo 1864 1956   Van Tassel, Flora Frank         spouse 2: Wolford, Hattie
Wainwright, Matilda 1851     Porter, James M            
Way, Dora M 1881 1950   Way, John            
Way, John 1866 1946   Way, Dora M            
Wightman, Elias   12-28-1866 73y10m27d              
Wightman, John   10-26-1841 21y10m20d              
Wightman, Tryphin   5-15-1829 1y21d              
Wilber, Abram 1848 1921   Thorington, Frances            
Wilber, Clara A 1852 1942   Scutt, Jacob H            
Wilber, Hobert J 1885 1961   Chichester, Nellie            
Williams, Nancy 1821 1896   Chapman, Harry            
Winans, Norma 1-8-1924     Berkner, Heinz            
Wolford, Hattie 1865 1945   Van Tassel, Lorenzo Frank          
Wood, Celestine 1859 1943   Taylor, Robert E            
Zeretzke, Cecilie 1911     Zeretzke, Erwin            
Zeretzke, Erwin 1903 1973   Zeretzke, Cecilie         Zeretzke, Josefa  
Zeretzke, Josefa 1878         Erwin        


Note 1
Submitted by Walt Mehrer (July 3, 2008)

My name is Walt Mehrer, a 10th generation Borthwick, I visited the Borthwick and Pinegrove cemeteries in June, and noticed from your listings in the pinegrove cemetery I have some information taken from the Borthwick family book of 1936. That might be of interest to other researchers now or in the future. Starting with George J Borthwick, His father and mother were James Borthwick 1794-1880 and Dalinda Dickinson 1797-1877, wife Polly Hagadorn 1815-1873, children in birth order; Hiram Sylvenns Borthwick, Lorenzo Madison Borthwick, Nancy Jane (Borthwick) Scutt, Dalinda Borthwick, Cornelia L. (Borthwick) Day, Hannah Matilda (Borthwick) Hisert, Orpha R. (borthwick) Whitcomb, Amelia (Borthwick) Scutt. Next; Nancy Jane (Borthwick) Scutt 6/22/1840-10/14/1921, Father and Mother were; George J Borthwick and Polly Hagadorn, Husband Richard Scutt, Children in birth order; George Stanley Scutt, Leola (Scutt) Richmond, Nellie Olive (Scutt) Estes, Leonard borthwick Scutt, Last but not least Nellie Olive (Scutt) Estes; Mother and Father was Nancy Jane and Richard Scutt. Husband was Charles Estes, and an unmarried son Leroy Estes.

A Note to Researchers using this Web-site: As you use this site, please keep in mind the difference between primary and secondary sources and the importance of building a preponderance of evidence. Accept nothing without further checking. It is our hope that through this collection of data from many sources, you will find a piece of the puzzle that you are working on and that may lead you to further discoveries.

Links to external web sites are being provided as a convenience and for informational purposes only; they do not constitute an endorsement or approval of any of the products, services or opinions contained in any external web site.

Welcome Page of the Schoharie County NYGenWeb Site
This page established June 26, 2006 and last updated November 09, 2009